Archbright Blog

Tales from the HR Hotline: IDEAL Edition

Written by Jenna Shellman, M.A., Director of IDEAL | Nov 20, 2026, 4:08:42 PM

Our Advisors field a wide range of HR and Safety questions from our members each day on the HR Hotline and Advisor Chat in mozzo. In this series, we're taking common, or sometimes incredibly unique, questions, similar to what we’ve received and sharing how our Advisor team would respond.

In this special IDEAL (Inclusion, Diversity, Equity, Accessibility, and Leadership) edition, we invited Archbright's Director of IDEAL, Jenna Shellman, to give her perspective on the scenarios alongside our advisor. We'll hear about a VP of Operations with poor brainstorming behavior, a member wondering how to roll out DEI training after an offensive ad campaign, and an office that is stumped on how to accommodate their team's cultural differences for team building events. 

The scenarios below are anonymized and reflect questions similar to those received by our team. They may combine elements from multiple real-world situations.

Question 1: I’ve gotten multiple reports from employees about our VP of Operation’s behavior in their all-staff meetings. They feel like they can’t bring any new ideas or suggestions forward because he shoots them down immediately and chastises the employee telling them why it would never work. They are all feeling shut down with some hoping to change teams to avoid reporting to him. What can we do to help him get less defensive and create a healthier team dynamic?

Sr. HR Advisor, Kathy Iverson:

A private meeting with HR and the VP sounds like it should be top order of business. Two things need to be brought to his attention: 2) How his actions are making people feel, and 2) what specific things he is doing that are making employees feel that way. I'd also recommend brainstorming some strategies for how he can better respond, including some active listening tips. Plan some follow-up meetings with employees so you can get feedback, and then meet with him to share what is going better and what challenges remain. Next phase would be helping him create some avenues to get that feedback himself, once some trust has been rebuilt with the team.

Director of IDEAL, Jenna Shellman:

The VP should receive direct feedback about the concerns employees are raising, along with clear expectations for how leaders should respond to ideas, disagreement, and feedback. Training or coaching on psychological safety, emotional intelligence, harassment awareness, and inclusion and belonging could help build the skills needed to create a healthier team environment.

It would also be helpful to give the VP specific strategies for encouraging productive dialogue. For example, using a “Yes, and” approach during brainstorming can help ensure ideas are explored before they are evaluated or dismissed. The VP could also establish structured brainstorming practices where employees first contribute ideas without critique, followed by a separate discussion about feasibility, risks, and next steps.

Because employees are already reporting that they feel shut down, rebuilding trust should also be intentional. Team-building activities that require collaboration, problem-solving, and sharing different perspectives, such as a survival exercise, escape room, or collaborative puzzle, may help. However, these activities should complement, rather than replace, ongoing changes in the VP’s day-to-day leadership behavior.

Related Archbright Resources: 

Archbright University courses that build communication and listening skills: 

Conflict to Collaboration

Emotional Intelligence at Work

Workplace Harassment Awareness: Inclusion In Action

mozzo® Microlearnings in the Video Training Library:

Active Listening - Asking Questions ( 3 Min)

The Importance of Positive Feedback (4 Min)

Question #2: Last week, our marketing team released a campaign that went viral for the wrong reasons. It came across as offensive to a marginalized group and nobody caught it or spoke up before it launched. In response, our CEO wants to introduce mandatory DEI training for the whole company. I’m supportive, but I don’t want the training to feel like a reaction to one team’s mistake. How can we approach this in a way that gets people genuinely interested and engaged?

Kathy:

Unfortunately, when people make mistakes, is often when things come to our attention or issues are brought to the surface. Training sounds like the correct next step here, even if it feels reactive to the recent events. The focus of the training should not be about the event or recent negative attention, but rather a generalized need for training that can benefit everyone. I would follow-up that training, with an individual session with the marketing team to address specific concerns as it relates to public relations, social media, etc.

Jenna:

I would avoid introducing companywide DEI training in a way that employees associate with punishment or one team’s mistake. Start by addressing the immediate concern with the marketing team, potentially bringing in an outside facilitator for targeted learning around bias, and how perspectives can be missed during the review and approval process.

Then, introduce broader inclusion training for all employees as part of the organization’s ongoing commitment to building an inclusive workplace, rather than as a direct response to the campaign. Create some space between the two efforts. When communicating why the companywide training is required, focus on practical goals such as inclusion, psychological safety, recognizing bias, and building the skills to navigate differences and speak up when something may have an unintended impact.

Related Archbright Resources:

Archbright University courses that support inclusion:

Strategies to Combat Microaggressions 

mozzo Microlearnings in the Video Training Library:

DEI in the Workplace (6 min)

Question #3: We have a very diverse, multi-cultural team. I want to plan team building events that resonate with everyone but am unsure of how to do that when we have multiple primary languages spoken and cultural food preferences that make it challenging to accommodate everyone at once. How can I get everyone engaged without making anyone feel left out?

Kathy:

Ask for volunteers to help plan events or allow folks to make suggestions for types of events or education that might be conducive to sharing your cultural differences. For example, some sort of potluck where different regions or cultures can be highlighted. Your employees may have some great ideas! Ask them!

Jenna:

Here are few team building activities that you can try to engage a multi-cultural team:

  • Build it together: Small groups receive materials such as blocks, cups, straws, or other tactile items and work together to recreate a structure or build toward a shared goal. The activity can be demonstrated visually, which will minimize the need for spoken instructions and encourage collaboration and problem-solving.
  • Picture scavenger hunt: Participants receive a series of pictures, symbols, or clues representing items or locations they need to find and will work together in pairs or small teams.
  • Copy the rhythm: A facilitator creates a simple rhythm by clapping, tapping, or using another sound or movement, and the group repeats the pattern. Participants can take turns leading as the rhythms change, creating a fun, low-pressure activity that promotes connection.
  • Movement as a driver: A facilitator or outside instructor leads the group through a movement-based activity, such as salsa dancing or Yin Yoga. The session would be light, low-pressure, and designed for varying abilities, with options such as chair dancing, seated movement, or modified poses so participants can engage in the way that works best for them. The focus is on shared movement, connection, and fun rather than performance or skill.

Thanks for reading this special edition of Tales from the HR Hotline, you can read more about IDEAL on our website.